Why directional communications matter for multi-domain operations
Show notes
Directional communications are becoming increasingly important as modern military operations demand higher data rates, greater bandwidth and resilient connectivity across multiple domains. In this episode, Wolfgang Schestak from Rohde & Schwarz explains how electronically steered AESA antennas focus transmission energy precisely where it is needed, enabling faster data exchange while reducing electromagnetic visibility and the risk of detection or interception. We discuss how directional links complement existing communications, such as SATCOM and conventional omnidirectional systems, how intelligent network management automatically selects the best available transmission paths, and how operators retain control over connectivity, data priorities and radio silence. Finally, NEMACS, Rohde & Schwarz’ emerging portfolio combining directional communications with intelligent communication management across multiple operational domains is adressed.
Show transcript
00:00:02: Welcome to Signals,
00:00:06: the defense podcast from Rohde &
00:00:08: Schwarz.
00:00:15: We're exploring why directional communications are becoming an important part of resilient multi-domain operations, how they differ from conventional omnidirectional transmission and how Rohde & Schwarz addresses this challenge.
00:00:31: I'm your host, Dennis P. Merklinghaus joined by my co-host Kadir Aydin.
00:00:36: Hi, everyone.
00:00:37: And joining us today is Wolfgang Schestak.
00:00:40: Thank you for having me, my name's Wolfgang Schestak.
00:00:43: I'm product manager of Multi-Domain Directional Communications at Rohde & Schwarz and I am looking forward to this nice podcast and hope I can give a couple of pieces of valuable information.
00:01:00: Modern military operations increasingly depend on information moving seamlessly between platforms across air, land, sea, space and cyberspace.
00:01:10: Sensors collect data, networks distribute it, decision-makers evaluate it, and platforms act on it.
00:01:18: The faster and more reliably this information flows, the more effectively a connected force can operate.
00:01:25: But there is a fundamental challenge.
00:01:28: Every wireless connection uses the electromagnetic spectrum and not every transmission needs to go in every direction, so what if we focus communications precisely where they are needed?
00:01:42: Could that help forces exchange more data, reduce their electromagnetic exposure and maintain connectivity?
00:01:53: Yeah, I think this is a particularly interesting topic because most of us think of wireless communication as something that simply connects two devices.
00:02:01: But in military environments the way your signal travels can be just as important as the information it carries.
00:02:09: Exactly. And to understand the advantage of directional communications.
00:02:13: Let's start with the bigger picture.
00:02:17: Modern military operations increasingly rely on information being exchanged between a growing number of crewed and uncrewed platforms.
00:02:26: Wolfgang, what does this mean for communications?
00:02:29: Well, if you look in the past there was actually no need to have a high bandwidth for example.
00:02:36: You had no sensors that collected huge amounts of data and this is changing now, with changing needs and the data-rate requirements of these sensors.
00:02:49: And to do this, you need to go to higher bands.
00:02:54: This gives an opportunity to combine with directional communications for several reasons.
00:03:01: One reason is that you can direct energy in a specific direction which is much more efficient than sending it omnidirectionally around your asset.
00:03:14: How exactly is it done?
00:03:15: So I know that there's a technology called AESA and this was used also in the radar world, but can you explain how that works?
00:03:23: because as you said omnidirectional was the thing so far.
00:03:27: Now directional becomes new technology.
00:03:29: Yes, so basically it's a quite easy story.
00:03:33: Instead of one antenna you have several antennas, be it fifty or a hundred, no matter and with these many antennas, you will have the opportunity to delay the receive and transmit time of the signal, which means if you delay it a little bit.
00:03:52: You can steer your angle of your beam to the direction you want to go and this is the great difference to the omnidirectional solution, where you just send all around. With directional communication,
00:04:06: you electronically steer the beam in the direction, transmit the data with higher bandwidth, with a higher data rate and less energy to the point you want to send it.
00:04:21: So basically I do use all of the power which I have into one direction instead of spreading everywhere?
00:04:28: And this technology comes with benefits?
00:04:31: Yeah!
00:04:33: Just compare it with a lighthouse.
00:04:35: If you have a lighthouse and compared to the church tower, which is lit from every direction, you see you need a hell of a lot of energy to light this church tower.
00:04:47: If there is a lighthouse that sends its light beam in a specific direction, for example, it has much brighter light in the direction you want to send it with the same energy.
00:04:59: And that is the same for RF. So you use this energy and transmit your data in exactly one direction where your asset which you want to communicate with is...
00:05:12: Okay!
00:05:12: That's a very nice picture.
00:05:14: So it is easy.
00:05:15: To get a better understanding.
00:05:16: Totally.
00:05:18: I come somehow from the world of omnidirectional communications buzzwords like TRANSEC and COMSEC, or hopping and encryption.
00:05:28: Is this still relevant when we are pointing the beam in one direction?
00:05:34: Or does it become
00:05:35: unnecessary?".
00:05:37: No!
00:05:37: It is as important. Even if the chance is much lower that it can be recorded by someone else, there is still a specific risk.
00:05:55: And to avoid these risks technologies like LPI and LPD are very important and also frequency hopping is something which is required for example, to avoid jamming on the one hand, or on the other hand,
00:06:11: to avoid that somebody else could pick up your data.
00:06:14: You mentioned LPI and LPD.
00:06:17: Does this mean that by using directional comms, it is harder to detect?
00:06:23: And thereby harder to
00:06:26: intercept?
00:06:27: Yes!
00:06:27: That's exactly the point... If you think about a current asset with omnidirectional communication, with omnidirectional antennas ...you fly like a Christmas tree.
00:06:40: You can see the asset from every direction because it sends all around.
00:06:44: If you have a narrow beam, it can be detected just in one direction for sure.
00:06:50: If the jammer or the radar stands exactly in this directionit could be recorded and disturbed.
00:07:01: If you fly into enemy territory, it's important.
00:07:04: Don't shine like a Christmas tree!
00:07:06: It is much better to have lights, like a car, for example, which lights exactly the direction of the road. Beside the road, you are not blinded by this light. And that is basically the same thing for directional communication.
00:07:23: That is why this is so important.
00:07:25: I love your analogies. Perfect.
00:07:29: Okay, I've been on an exhibition last week and what I observed there was that at almost every booth there was an uncrewed system, be it a surface ship, be it something flying and all of them were equipped with SATCOM.
00:07:43: No one was talking about directional comms.
00:07:45: So is that a completely new topic?
00:07:48: Is that the reason why nobody was showcasing it or is this just something emerging?
00:07:53: So where we as Rohde & Schwarz can provide the technology to not pop up on radar for instance?
00:08:00: So basically the directional communication is a quite new topic.
00:08:05: It started with fighters of the fifth generation, if you mention SATCOM—basically this also directional communication.
00:08:12: You need to steer your beam directly into the satellite and back.
00:08:15: So at the end of the day, directional communication isn't something new but the difference that satellite networks can be jammed too And if you rely on satellite only you might lose your connection and in combination with directional communication.
00:08:33: In the higher bands, you have all advantages of satellite transmission.
00:08:39: but on a second path if you are jammed by the SATCOM radios You still can send data via the directional communication even if you need some relays to reach the control station you intended to send data.
00:08:55: Okay, so you said that SATCOM is also directional.
00:08:58: Are we talking about similar angles when it comes to SATCOM and directional communication, as they are called?
00:09:04: Basically, it depends on the band you are using or technology.
00:09:09: Maybe all of you know this parabolic antenna for satellite television.
00:09:14: So this is basically also a kind of directional communication.
00:09:19: But with the new technologies, with our AESA technology you do it electronically which consumes much less real estate on planes or drones and that's the big advantage.
00:09:32: Okay, now with satellite communications you have a ground station and the satellites, which are more or less stationary assets. With two moving platforms like an uncrewed asset and a fighter jet, you have moving platforms.
00:09:48: How do you make sure that connectivity is given?
00:09:52: So basically we come to the edge of physics.
00:09:56: Directional communication is a really hard topic.
00:09:59: it's not alone the AESA antenna which is known from radars or whatever.
00:10:05: But the difference is to arrange all these data transfers over a wide band of speeds, a wide band of environmental conditions.
00:10:15: And basically, this is, as my engineering colleagues always say, at the edge of physics and I think that's big advantage for our solution we do what is possible but just limited by physical constraints.
00:10:33: Okay, so how do you make sure that the beam is pointing into the right direction.
00:10:38: Where is the counterpart?
00:10:39: So basically this is defined.
00:10:44: by the technology and I can explain a little bit around it.
00:10:47: So we set up a network between assets, with these networks all assets know where others are.
00:10:54: Via the AESA technology you define direction of arrival on the beam and so forth.
00:11:02: At the end, if this net entry is done The assets know where they are.
00:11:08: They know how fast they're moving, and they know how to steer the antenna beam to reach the asset that they want to
00:11:15: reach.
00:11:17: Okay!
00:11:17: So far we've been talking about point-to-point communication but in reality we have networks... We have multiple nodes in the network.
00:11:26: so how does this network work basically?
00:11:29: How is it created...?
00:11:32: How is the communication routed?
00:11:34: Is there an operator sitting and making sure that everyone is connected to everyone, or anything else.
00:11:40: Can you make a deep dive here?
00:11:43: Sure, I can do so. For sure,
00:11:45: we don't need the lady from... telephone exchange, who plugs together the lines.
00:11:50: So this is working automatically and for this topic we developed a specific software suite which is called the Communication Management Suite.
00:12:01: And this Communication Management Suite is aware of all network participants.
00:12:07: It knows where they are.
00:12:10: It is also aware of the performance.
00:12:15: So the communication management suite can say which route is best.
00:12:20: Maybe in some cases it's not a direct route, but you go via one or two hops and transmit more data as if you would connect to another asset directly.
00:12:32: And that is basically the beauty of the Communication Management Suite, that this part of software allows to set up your network and send your data via the best possible channel.
00:12:46: And this might not only be one network, it's like there is no direct communication between assets that may also go through the SATCOM link.
00:12:57: That is really a giant advantage for users.
00:13:01: they can have or are sure their data will transmit in the fastest way.
00:13:09: Okay, but as an operator am I still able to forbid some sort of communication?
00:13:38: Disallowed?
00:13:40: For sure.
00:13:40: So the communication management suite is also responsible for switching data links to radio silence, so this is really an important thing.
00:13:50: if you want to fly covert into enemy territory You must not be visible and your mission planning works well.
00:14:02: It's not necessary to have always the radios turned on.
00:14:07: You can fly covertly to the place you want to reassemble for example and then switch the radio on againand the whole distance between the switch off of the radio.
00:14:20: and the next switch-on of the radio are invisible in the electromagnetic spectrum.
00:14:26: Okay, in order to use that network I assume all the participants must be connected.
00:14:33: But it is also crucial that the amount of data or transmission is at a minimum so that I do not appear on screen.
00:14:43: Does this system care about keeping the level of data to a minimum?
00:14:51: Or something which isn't considered right now?
00:14:56: For sure it is, but that always depends on the requirements.
00:15:01: So you have your mission plan.
00:15:02: The mission plan defines the basic mission scenario and also defines the performance of your radios.
00:15:09: If the operator decides to have a long time without communication it will be switched off.
00:15:17: But if there are very important data where the operator says even if I would expect the asset to be on radio silence, but if this data is available it needs to send it.
00:15:29: This can be done too.
00:15:31: So basically, we have quality-of-service classes and there's huge flexibility in that And basically, the definition for the mission will be done beforehand.
00:15:46: Talking about directional comms being a kind of future for communications, will this replace legacy systems?
00:15:55: For sure it won't.
00:15:57: Because there are different use cases.
00:15:59: If you take, for example, air traffic communication This is necessary in peacetime.
00:16:05: There's no discussion whether it can be switched off or not.
00:16:10: Also in wartime you will have access to the air traffic controllers.
00:16:16: You need it for flying in your own area, there might be civil ones or military ones and for these skies, you will need classical omnidirectional communication, for sure.
00:16:30: you can also use this for C2 messages.
00:16:33: If you are using something like this As said, omnidirectional communication will persist.
00:16:40: There might be changes if you fly in the enemy territory.
00:16:46: there You have no own air traffic control and so you don't care about it And then you can switch off.
00:16:54: Then you have directional communication which is much less visible than the omni-directional communication.
00:17:01: Perfect. Dear listeners, you might have heard our previous episode about NEMEX and this is exactly what we're talking here.
00:17:10: Yes, NEMEX was introduced at ILA this year basically the product line of Rohde & Schwarz which works with directional communication.
00:17:21: It's not specifically designed for air domain.
00:17:25: It also covers other domains like the Navy or also in space operations.
00:17:32: And with NEMEX, we will offer a portfolio in the future that does — the best of directional communication and the best of communication
00:17:43: management.
00:17:44: Well, dear listener,
00:17:45: Now you heard everything about directional communications which is a complicated topic and just as Wolfgang said it's at the edge of physics.
00:17:54: We heard about the lighthouse versus the church tower We heard about the Christmas tree versus the flashlight, which are perfect analogies for this topic.
00:18:05: So if you want to deep dive into this just contact us or go on our web page.
00:18:10: Follow us on social media channels.
00:18:13: Thank you very much, Wolfgang,
00:18:14: For being here.
00:18:16: Thank you for having me.
00:18:18: And that is it. Hear you later.
00:18:22: Bye.
New comment